Author
|
Topic: Alpha Centauri
|
Shyn Ensign
|
posted December 09, 2001 11:15
Someone asked in the past week what aliens it would be cool to see on Enterprise.At the time, there was something I was trying to remember that I don't think anyone else mentioned. Well, now I finally remembered--though the thread appears to have disappeared. Alpha Centauri. I remember there was a neat book that came out once--gray/silver cover and it was an encylopedia of alien races from the Star Trek universe. I'm sure it wasn't "canon"--the Klingon homeworld, for example, was called Kling instead of Q'onos--but the stories about first contact with each race were really entertaining. If I recall correctly, the people of Alpha Centauri look perfectly human...and I think in the timeline presented in this reference, these were actually the first aliens contacted rather than the Vulcans. (So much for that history now, right?) And it was a logical first contact given that it's the closest star to Sol. I think this reference mentioned something about how humans were relieved that the first outworlders looked just like them. (Though, of course, they certainly weren't going to be the last human-looking alien race.)
Still, I think it would be really neat if we could have an Enterprise episode where we see Alpha Centauri and learn something about the people who live there. Sure, they look perfectly human (at least if we follow the encylopedia), but what about the culture(s) on this world? And what about the history of this planet and its first contact with Earth?
Aside from a TOS novel about Dr. McCoy's daughter, I'm not aware of any other references to Alpha Centauri in any Star Trek story. This is an alien race I'd really like to see in a future Enterprise episode.
|
Colonel Worf Rear Admiral
|
posted December 09, 2001 14:21
Humans settled on Alpha Centauri.
|
Captain Augustson Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 09, 2001 15:49
Depending on what you read, Alpha Centauri was populated with Humans by the Preservers long ago. Alpha Centaurians are Human, but obviously developed their own culture. They ARE supposed to be one of the founding members of the Federation. Again, it depends on what you read and what is considered 'canon', though I don't think this subject has ever been mentioned in any of the series.------------------ "Unrelenting in the pursuit of knowledge" - U.S.S. Relentless
|
Intelligence Captain
|
posted December 09, 2001 16:21
It seems to me you’re speaking of “The Worlds of the Federation” by Shane Johnson. IIRC it is a rip off of the FASA/SFC universe.The Alpha Centaurians are ancient Greeks that were settled by the Preservers on the eight planet. The UNSS Icarus made contact with them in 2048. The same book states Cochrane to be inhabitant of those Centauri.
------------------ Enter the Captain's Lounge
|
Fitz Lt. J.G.
|
posted December 09, 2001 16:28
quote: the Klingon homeworld, for example, was called Kling instead of Q'onos
But Kling is canon. It was the name of the homeworld during TNG's 1st season. [This message has been edited by Fitz (edited December 09, 2001).]
|
Orion Randy Fleet Captain
|
posted December 09, 2001 16:37
quote: Originally posted by Fitz: But Kling is canon. It was the name of the homeworld during TNG's 1st season.
Shhhh! The gushers don't want to hear about canon! Seriously, I can't help but think they've bypassed Alpha Centauri because TPTB have forgotten it altogether. Or perhaps they think we'll confuse it with Lost In Space. ------------------ Randy Orion Press For Excellence in Star Trek Fanzines http://www.fastcopyinc.com/orionpress
|
st63z Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 09, 2001 16:38
Man, I thought you guys were gonna talk about the Meier game...
|
USS Pioneer Commodore
|
posted December 09, 2001 16:42
quote: Originally posted by Fitz: That's no error. Kling was the name of the homeworld during TNG's 1st season.
The reference to Kling was made by Korris in "Heart Of Glory" as an intended reference to the Klingon Howeworld early in TNG....but was subsequently changed into a more 'exotic' name by ST VI. The ST:Encyclopedia rationalizes this by asserting that the reference was either made to a prominent city or a district on the Klingon Homworld. Other references to Qo'nos (Kronos) before TUC name include Picard's reference to the 'First City' in "Sin Of The Father". [It's quite possible the 'First City' or some major capitol on Kronos is referred to as Kling OR that Korris was simply referring to Kronos in a non-native style reference, since Korris assumed that Worf was still unfamiliar with his Klingon background.] ---------------- "If continuity is not important, then Commander, why make it canon?"
|
SchwEnt Commander
|
posted December 09, 2001 17:02
...I believe you're speaking of my all-time fave, the original Star Trek Spaceflight Chronology--the first Paramount-licenced ST chronology, circa TMP. Others have based their own chronologies on this volume (FASA, Johnson, etc.).And since you brought it up, here is a summary of their long lost ST history: SPACEFLIGHT CHRONOLOGY 1957 Sputnik I launched 1961 Vostok I carries first man into space, Yuri Gagarin 1969 Apollo 11 lands first men on the Moon 1980 Space Shuttle begins flights 1982 Galileo probe leaves for Jupiter Lunar Polar Orbiter studies Moon 1983 Hubble Space Telescope is orbited Venus Atmospheric Balloon studies Venus 1985 Halley Comet Probe flyby with comet 1986 Asteroid Probes begin asteroid rendezvous missions 1988 Mars Sample Return Mission launched 1991 Saturn Dual Probe (Cassini) arrives at Saturn 1992 Space Shuttle completes its 12 years of service 1994 Manned mission to the Moon begin again 1996 DY-100 class ships enter service, and becomes the first manned ship to Mars Eugenics Wars end Khan Noonian Singh leave Earth in DY-100 sleeper ship 1998 Goddard Moonbase opens, the first large scale international space project 1999 Asteroid Belt Lander confirm asteroids have raw materials suitable for industry 2001 Mercury Rover sends back soil samples 2002 Construction begins on the first L-5 city 2003 United Space Initiative agreement signed, to focus and accelerate exploration of the Solar System Lindbergh class Space Ferry (X-33 VentureStar) replaces Space Shuttle 2004 First major expansion of Goddard Moonbase Farside Moonbase radio telescope operations begin Mass Driver in use at Moon's Clavius mines 2005 First spacechild born at Goddard Moonbase 2006 Thomas Morrison, first person to die in space at Goddard Moonbase 2007 Tsiolkovskygrad, first L-5 city, opens with 250 in residence 2008 Aventeur class of fission ships enter service, first ships assembled in Earth orbit 2009 Second L-5 city opens 2010 First space census reveal 1500 people living off Earth Solar Power Satellite system accounts for 40% of US energy use 2012 Marsbase One opens 2013 DY-300 prototype has serious flaws and nevers enters service 2014 Space Homesteading Act allows pioneers to acquire property in Solar System First manned mission to Jupiter launched 2015 Marsbase Two opens Stellar series launched, first interstellar probes 2017 U Thant Stellar probe finds large amounts of antimatter in interstellar void 2018 Marsbase Three begins studying Martian moon Phobos and Deimos for mining First homesteaders leave for Asteroid Belt 2019 Temporary mining base established on Phobos 2020 First manned mission to Saturn reveals evidence of alien visitation 2021 Fossil lifeform remains discovered on Mars 2022 DY-500 ship UNSS Courageous cannot return home, 62 lives lost 2023 Fusion R&D funds increased for use in spaceship propulsion 2024 Venus Terraforming project receives approval 2025 Twelve probes sent into Jupiter's Red Spot 2026 Capital city of Asteroid Belt, Asteropolis, opens 2027 Terraforming of Venus begins 2028 Jupiter Base opens on Ganymede 2029 Project SETI succeeds with first extraterrestrial communications rec'd at Farside Moonbase 2C 2031 Second base opens on Ganymede 2032 Second generation of interstellar probes launched 2034 UN commissions United Nations Solar Fleet Saturn Base opens on Titan 2035 Major setback with the loss of Advanced Fusion Prototype One, all lives lost 2037 Spacefarms, huge orbiting constructions, become new food supply for Earth 2038 Crew training begins for first interstellar missions 2039 Pluto Base opens 2040 Solar Spacelines begins first interplanetary commerical travel for tourists 2041 UNSS Adameve, first interstellar manned mission, leaves for Barnard's Star 2042 UNSS Icarus leaves for Alpha Centauri 2044 Interplanetary Communication Network established 2047 Venus Terraforming Project succeeds with opening of North Pole Base on Venus 2048 UNSS Icarus makes first contact with humanoid life at Alpha Centauri Zefram Cochrane of Alpha Centauri presents warp drive theory to UNSS Icarus crew, who transmit news to Earth 2051 Interplanetary super cargo carriers boost solar trade and industry 2052 First contact news and warp drive theory rec'd on Earth, Warp Drive Studies Program begin 2054 UNSS Icarus returns to Earth, UN mission dispatched to Alpha Centauri 2055 Warp Drive One prototype is first vessel to exceed the speed of light 2058 UNSS Bonaventure undergoes testing as Earth's first warp drive ship 2059 UNSS Bonaventure leaves on first mission to Tau Ceti UN mission arrives at Alpha Centauri to establish formal relations Advanced Pluto base opens 2060 Warp drive ship UNSS Powell leaves for Alpha Centauri 2061 UNSS Powell returns to Earth with Zefram Cochrane Solar Spacelines offers tourist cruises to view Halley's Comet 2062 Fundamental Declaration of the Martian Colonies grant autonomy to inhabited solar system regions 2064 Rapid improvements in warp drive technology result in new Verne class ships 2065 Disabled Vulcan ship rescued by UN Solar Fleet, diplomatic relations established 2066 Earth's first warp drive ship, UNSS Bonaventure, lost on its third mission 2068 Pluto base reveals proof of pulsating universe First Vulcan delegation is welcomed on Earth 2069 First contact with Andorians 2070 For next three years, 10 Space Arks with disenchanted families leave Earth, never to return 2071 Undeclared alliance of nearby star systems continue to expand diplomatic, cultural and commerical ties 2072 Tellarites claim Earth's Solar System. The incident is resolved peacefully and an ally is gained 2074 Warp Radio introduced 2077 Unofficial diplomatic meeting discusses possibility of alliance of Earth, Alpha Centauri, Vulcan, Andor, and Tellar 2078 Messier class ships enter service, the last entirely Earth built series. 2079 Rigel trading planets visited 2082 First call for a "United Federation" fails to win approval 2083 First Earth-alien crews begin working together 2087 United Federation of Planets incorporated at first Babel Conference. Stardates adopted as Federation's principal interstellar time system 2088 Space census reveals Earth population at ten billion, with eight million residing in space 2089 Space war games disaster speeds up chartering of academy proposal to establish crew training standards 2091 Starfleet Academy opens with a class of 300 Bone setting laser perfected 2092 USS Muleskinner spacejacked by pirates (later to be identified as Romulans) 2093 Horizon class enters service, first UFP sponsored starship 2094 Outpost Delta VII destroyed by pirates (later to be identified as Romulans) 2095 Starbase program begins with opening of Starbase One 2097 USS Archon lost near Beta III system 2099 In worst "pirating" incident yet, transport Diana plundered and 500 passengers killed 2102 Federation tensions mount as outlying sectors fear "pirates" may not be merely renegades 2103 Seven Romulan ships destroy Starbase One. Not knowing the attackers identity, the Federation institutes Mobilization Alert 2104 Advanced laser weaponry, in development for eight years, is approved for use on Horizon class ships 2105 Marshall class destroyers rushed into service, to be prime defender of the Federation in the event of war Sectors 1-4 and 7-10 go to Code 1 Alert Status 2106 Romulans ambush USS Patton near Rigel system, Romulan War begins 2107 Romulans destroy important Federation resource at Sector 5B Mining Complex Sector 7 Wing Fleet is victorious over an entire Romulan armada 2108 Romulans kill 200,000 at Alpha Omega B in worst incident of the war 2109 Romulan War ends with decisive victory for Federation at Battle of Cheron 2113 UFP membership reaches 100 Starbase One rebuilt and towed to original location 2114 Prototype battlecruiser built for Romulan War fails Starfleet requirements and is put in storage 2115 Pyrimiis star system found to contain two inhabited planets in same orbit on collision course 2117 Top secret spy ship achieves fastest speed to date, warp 3.84 2118 Galactic Cultural Exchange begins 2120 Remains of galaxy's oldest civilization discovered on Planet 522-IV, 7.5 billion years old 2121 Starfleet Museum opens on Memory Alpha 2122 Subspace Radio introduced 2123 First interstellar liners, the Declaration class, begin service 2124 First evidence of extra-galactic life with discovery of alien probe in Sector 24 2125 UFP's major space development complex, Centauri Spaceworks, opens 2127 Largest nova in recorded history (Phi Puma star) observed by doomed research ship Kepler 2130 First violation of Prime Directive by Captain James Smithson 2135 Theory of molecular integration achieves major breakthrough with successful transmission of organic life 2136 Funding for new starships not approved, Marshall and Horizon class remain in service 2138 Interplanetary war near Neutral Zone escalates tensions between Federation and Romulan Empire 2141 Intelligent flying humanoids found on Alpha Virginis II in Sector 14C 2143 UFP planetary weather control turns unproductive worlds productive 2144 Stellarford class liners are most opulent passenger vessels yet 2147 Medical tricorder invented 2148 First new major starship in 43 years, Tritium class, features new three nacelle design that proves unworkable 2151 First contact with Klingon Empire 2152 Federation's largest propulsion and weaponry facility, the Arcturus Test Range, opens 2153 USS Valiant is lost near Vendikar system 2154 Mann class starship launched, first ships to surpass warp four 2155 Orpheus probe transmits data as it descends into a black hole 2157 Back-to-Earth movement proclaimed 2161 Billion ton superconvoys save trillions of credits and years of travel time 2162 Prototype military carrier is Starfleet's largest ship to date: 1,989,000 tons 2163 Back-to-Earth movement gains strength 2165 Largest spacelift in history, 10 million people of Bayard's Planet are evacuated before Phi Puma supernova of 2127 strikes 2166 Theta VII becomes 500th member of UFP 2167 Inhabited waterworld of Hydra II in Sector 16C is discovered 2168 Galactic Cultural Exchange Project celebrates 50 years 2169 CR-594 Construction Rig permits small fleets of ships to be built at one time 2170 Fastest ship to date enters service, the Baton Rouge class--first ship with transporters, last without dilithium 2171 Richard Daystrom introduces duotronics breakthrough in computer development 2172 Disapproval with UFP inner workings cause members to question present structure 2174 Transporter becomes reality as first experiment using human subject is successful 2175 Continued discord with UFP policy cripples economic strength 2476 Rigel XII Mining Complex discovers dilithium properties 2177 Resolution to dissolve the Federation is introduced at Babel conference. Crisis is averted 2179 R&D for Subspace Radio results in warp 20 transmission velocity 2182 Construction begins on Constitution class starships 2183 Daystrom's M-1 computer prototype fails to perform as expected 2184 Largest space rescue recovers 600 passengers from starliner Juliana 2186 Dilithium crystals are integrated into new generation of warp engines 2188 Constitution class starships enter service 2190 USS Wells travels through time and returns from three years mission in 33 days 2193 Debris from USS Ajax found in the form of a comet 2195 Starbase 25 opens in this 100th year of starbase operations 2198 New weapon system undergoes testing: phasers 2199 Extra-galactic probe design completed based on "superwarp" (transwarp) theory 2207 USS Enterprise begins a five year mission under Captain James T. Kirk
|
Fitz Lt. J.G.
|
posted December 09, 2001 17:02
quote: The ST:Encyclopedia rationalizes this by asserting that the reference was either made to a prominent city or a district on the Klingon Homworld.
That doesn't explain why a planet on the map in "Conspiracy" was labeled with "Kling".
|
Apocalypse Cow Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 09, 2001 17:10
It dosen't explain why Americans call Germany "Germany", while the Germans call it "Deutschland,"(sp?) either. Maps are labled both ways all the time, though usually only with one or the other.Go figure. I guess we're just living in one huge continuity error, huh? Damn B&B to Hell! They're in league with Lucifer (or Satan, or Beelzebub, or Mephistopheles, or the Devil, or... well, I guess depends on who you're talking to, huh?), I tells ya!
[This message has been edited by Apocalypse Cow (edited December 09, 2001).]
|
USS Pioneer Commodore
|
posted December 09, 2001 17:36
quote: Originally posted by Fitz: That doesn't explain why a planet on the map in "Conspiracy" was labeled with "Kling".
The assumption in the Encyclopedia remains only conjecture, of course, but likely doesn't take into account the reference on the Galactic Map. If this is the case, then the reference to Kling (as previously stated) might have been a 'Terran' equivalent made by Korris which is also documented in Federation maps and references. [But it remains curious however that references to 'Kronos' were still made in the 23rd century by the UFP president and Valeris.] We might also entertain the possibility that Kling itself is the reference to the Klingon star system, rather than the planet itself. ---------------- "If continuity is not important, then Commander, why make it canon?"
|
Bulldog19 Commander
|
posted December 09, 2001 19:50
quote: Originally posted by Fitz: That doesn't explain why a planet on the map in "Conspiracy" was labeled with "Kling".
For the same reason that Earth is called "Earth", "Terra" or "Sol III"- a planet can have more than one name, just like a country can (The United States" or simply "America".) ------------------ Shale! It's all shale! "If God does not exist, then anything is permitted"- Fyodor Dostoevsky
|
MajorBarcalow Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 09, 2001 20:15
The Alpha Centauri are almost looking like humans. They look like us outside, but inside, their internal organs are different.They are also very different in that they are spiritual and do holistic things. Zefran Cochran was supposed to be from Alpha Centauri but the lousy writers of First Contact botched this up and of course the lousy lazy writers of Enterprise aren't fixing nothing.
|
Polaris Lieutenant
|
posted December 09, 2001 20:30
[QUOTE]Originally posted by USS Pioneer: We might also entertain the possibility that Kling itself is the reference to the Klingon star system, rather than the planet itself.Besides most people agree that "Kling" sounds silly. If the planet were called "Kling" it would problably then be more proper to call the race "Klingers" instead of Klingons. And despite what Riker said in "Liasons", Worf would look awfull in a dress. [This message has been edited by Polaris (edited December 09, 2001).]
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim Commander
|
posted December 09, 2001 21:11
Kling is just an alternate name referring to the same place.Kling, Klingon, The Klingon Homeworld, Qo'nos, Kronos, etc... Just like Vulcan, Vulcanis, Vulcania, etc... Just like Earth, Terra, Sol III, etc... Just like Andor, Andoria, etc... Just like Talax, Talaxia, etc... Need I go on? This ain't nothin' new, folks! -MMoM
|
bolian12 Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 09, 2001 23:05
Seeing Alpha Centauri would be great. The inhabitants would be called the Centauri, they would be almost identical to humans except they would have hair crests like peacocks. Their name for their homeworld would be Centayri Prime and their government would be called the Centauri Republic.
|
Apocalypse Cow Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 09, 2001 23:08
quote: Originally posted by bolian12: Seeing Alpha Centauri would be great. The inhabitants would be called the Centauri, they would be almost identical to humans except they would have hair crests like peacocks. Their name for their homeworld would be Centayri Prime and their government would be called the Centauri Republic.
Don't forget the ice powers.
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim Commander
|
posted December 09, 2001 23:11
So...um...What's wrong with AC being uninhabited? We've never seen anything to suggest that any race other than humans live there, and I think it would jive well with that line in "Terra Nova" or whatever ep it was about there not being an inhabited planet within xLY from Earth, or whatever it said. Why does AC have to be inhabited by an intelligent species? (Besides Earth colonists.) -MMoM
|
MajorBarcalow Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 09, 2001 23:42
quote: Originally posted by The Mighty Monkey of Mim: So...um...What's wrong with AC being uninhabited? We've never seen anything to suggest that any race other than humans live there, and I think it would jive well with that line in "Terra Nova" or whatever ep it was about there not being an inhabited planet within xLY from Earth, or whatever it said. Why does AC have to be inhabited by an intelligent species? (Besides Earth colonists.) -MMoM
Maybe because it's already been established in Trek that the Alpha Cenariens are a humanoid race already indigenous to Alpha Centauri? Zefran Cochran is an Alpha Cenataurean.
|
zeus759 Lieutenant
|
posted December 10, 2001 00:23
Is Cochran a native ACian or did he just move there after inventing Warp drive? I personally like the idea that HUMANS came up with warp drive all by their lonesome rather than a hand out from AC. Also, that whole Preservers shat really gets under my skin. Didnt these folks have something better to do than take a buncha greeks and move them one star over? Just my 2 cents.
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim Commander
|
posted December 10, 2001 00:26
quote: Originally posted by MajorBarcalow: Maybe because it's already been established in Trek that the Alpha Cenariens are a humanoid race already indigenous to Alpha Centauri? Zefran Cochran is an Alpha Cenataurean.
Erm...no. No such thing has ever been established. Cochrane was a HUMAN, dude. Have you not even seen Star Trek: First Contact? He just moved to AC after he invented Warp Drive. (For humans, of course.) This is what people have been trying so hard to explain to you, Major. All that stuff you seem to think has been 'established', HASN'T. That stuff from the sourcebooks and FASA and Worlds of the Federation is all non-canon. In other words, it doesn't count. (At least not in the official view of the ST universe.) The only stuff that is canon (the only stuff that counts) are the shows themselves, and the Okuda and Sternbach reference books. Anything else is disregardable in the sense that it may be discounted by TPTB at any time. It is not kept track of, nor is it consulted or adhered to as the shows continue. The majority of it has no validity. Do you understand? Nothing in any onscreen Trek (TOS or otherwise) confirms what you have said, and in fact, some stuff has CONTRADICTED IT, as I've said. Get it? -MMoM
[This message has been edited by The Mighty Monkey of Mim (edited December 10, 2001).]
|
Nerys Myk Lt. J.G.
|
posted December 10, 2001 00:32
quote: Originally posted by MajorBarcalow: Maybe because it's already been established in Trek that the Alpha Cenariens are a humanoid race already indigenous to Alpha Centauri? Zefran Cochran is an Alpha Cenataurean.
All that was established was that Cochrane was "from" there. They never said how he got there. Since FC shows that he's an Earthman/human/Terran I suspect he moved there from Earth. Much in the same way I moved from Texas to California and went from being a Texan to being a Californian.
Mike
------------------ "Nothing is real" -Strawberry Fields Lennon & McCartney
|
MajorBarcalow Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 10, 2001 06:39
It WAS established that Zefran Cochran was an Alpha BEFORE First Contact came along and ruined the continuity.Zefran Cochran discovered warp drive at the same time that Vulcan, Andor, Teler, and Earth did. Then all those races met each other and fought as they explored outer space and tried to colonize the sam planets. The First Contact came along and put this into the garbage with the trash. Enterprise puts more bad garbage on top.
|
bolian12 Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 10, 2001 07:05
quote: Originally posted by MajorBarcalow: Then all those races met each other and fought as they explored outer space and tried to colonize the sam planets. .
Interesting, I've never heard of these "Sam Planets." That sounds like a great idea for an episode of "Enterprise." All of the races would fight for control of the Sam System. BTW: Why the gre'thor would they all develope warp simultaneously?
|
MrGleep Lieutenant
|
posted December 10, 2001 07:20
quote: Originally posted by MajorBarcalow: The Alpha Centauri are almost looking like humans. They look like us outside, but inside, their internal organs are different.
Don't they also have an extra joint in their fingers or something?
|
MrGleep Lieutenant
|
posted December 10, 2001 07:29
quote: Originally posted by MajorBarcalow: It WAS established that Zefran Cochran was an Alpha BEFORE First Contact came along and ruined the continuity.
Cite your source, please?
|
Bulldog19 Commander
|
posted December 10, 2001 14:39
There are only two canon references to Alpha Centauri in Trek, both from TOS episodes "Tomorrow is Yesterday" (a throw away line Kirk that doesn't really establish anything) and "Metamorphosis". It is in this second episode that Kirk, when Cochrane identifies himself, says "Zephram Cochrane? Of Alpha Centauri?" This always led me to believe that Cochrane was originally from Centauri but it seems I was wrong, as "First Contact" has Cochrane as a Terran. The only explination for this is that Cochrane had his warp 5 test facility at Alpha Centauri, although we get no hint of that in First Contact or in Broken Bow.I am disappointed that Trek has basically ignored Alpha Centauri, unless it has been established that the system was intially uninhabited, only to be later colonized by Earth. But it would seem that there are no native Centauri races. ------------------ Shale! It's all shale! "If God does not exist, then anything is permitted"- Fyodor Dostoevsky
|
SchwEnt Commander
|
posted December 10, 2001 15:13
Yeah. First things first, TOS canon, "Metamorphosis" eps.Kirk says, "Zefram Cochrane? Of Alpha Centauri?" THAT'S canon!! Now you tell me me, how the hell do you interpret that?? Which is the more likely conclusion after hearing that line: 1) Zefram Cochrane is from Alpha Centauri -or- 2) Zefram Cochrane is a colonist who ended up on Alpha Centauri How about "Charles DeGaulle? Of France?" "Abe Lincoln? Of America" "Papa Doc? Of Haiti?" Really, what's the most likely conclusion with Kirk's line?? ZC is FROM AC!!
|
Theodore Jay Miller Fleet Captain
|
posted December 10, 2001 15:48
quote: Originally posted by SchwEnt: Kirk says, "Zefram Cochrane? Of Alpha Centauri?"THAT'S canon!! Now you tell me me, how the hell do you interpret that?? Which is the more likely conclusion after hearing that line: 1) Zefram Cochrane is from Alpha Centauri -or- 2) Zefram Cochrane is a colonist who ended up on Alpha Centauri How about "Charles DeGaulle? Of France?" "Abe Lincoln? Of America" "Papa Doc? Of Haiti?"
I could interpret the line either way. Ever hear of Lawrence of Arabia? T.E.Lawrence wasn't born in Arabia, he became famous there in later life. Lincoln, DeGaulle, and Papa Doc are famous for RULING the countries you mention, and would be associated with those countries even if they'd been born elsewhere. If someone says he's Abe Lincoln, the response would be "PRESIDENT Abe Lincoln?" or "Abe Lincoln as in Gettyburg Address?", references to his fame, rather than "Abe Lincoln of Kentucky?", a reference to his birthplace. Cochrane could easily be from Earth, but have become associated with Alpha Centauri later in life. One possible sequence of events: After the loss of the Terra Nova colony, the already-famous Cochrane was instrumental in leading the colonization of the closer but much less Earthlike Alpha Centauri. This was key to keeping Earth's colonization program going, Cochrane is known as "The Father of Alpha Centauri" as much as "The Discoverer of the Space Warp", and Kirk referred to both roles in "Metamorphosis".
|
Bulldog19 Commander
|
posted December 10, 2001 16:09
Good point about Lincoln. He was born in Kentucky but people call him "Lincoln from Illinois." Still not really satisfied with this but it logical. But I'd still like to see Cochrane as a native Centauri!------------------ Shale! It's all shale! "If God does not exist, then anything is permitted"- Fyodor Dostoevsky
|
trowa0300 Lt. Cmdr.
|
posted December 10, 2001 16:29
indeed very good point with Lincoln. Illinois is called the Land of Lincoln, because he spent much of his life there and his political career started there. Also good points about rulers being associated with the places they rule. Napoleon is often considered French when he is really ethnically Italian. He was born in Corsica!------------------ God is in his Heaven, All's right with the world...... -NERV
|
Intelligence Captain
|
posted December 10, 2001 18:58
quote: Originally posted by trowa0300: Napoleon is often considered French when he is really ethnically Italian. He was born in Corsica!
Corsica, French Island in the Mediterranean. 1300 to Genova, 1768 to France
Napoléon Bonaparte (Napoleone Buonaparte) *Ajacciao (Corsica) Aug 15, 1769 Technically he was French (and involved in globalisation) But back to topic, has someone read the book Federation? Cochrane is depicted as being an Earth citizen that moved to Alpha Centauri. ------------------ Enter the Captain's Lounge
|
AlexR Moderator
|
posted December 10, 2001 19:03
quote: Originally posted by The Mighty Monkey of Mim: This is what people have been trying so hard to explain to you, Major. All that stuff you seem to think has been 'established', HASN'T. That stuff from the sourcebooks and FASA and Worlds of the Federation is all non-canon. In other words, it doesn't count. (At least not in the official view of the ST universe.) The only stuff that is canon (the only stuff that counts) are the shows themselves, and the Okuda and Sternbach reference books.
Actually, unless they're directly citing something already stated on filnm someplace, not even the Okuda and Sternbach books count. They're speculating, too. They've done a lot of very good speculation, but also some not-so-good speculation, not tomention the conjectures they've made that TPTB have contradicted on film, anyway. It happens. Nature o' the beast. Best, Alex
|
The Mighty Monkey of Mim Commander
|
posted December 11, 2001 00:51
quote: Originally posted by Bulldog19: But I'd still like to see Cochrane as a native Centauri!
Well, it ain't gonna happen, buddy. He was a human. That was concretely established in the movie. Unless of course he was really an alien who landed on Earth as a child and was adopted by Terrans and grew up never knowing the truth... ...Oh wait, wrong series. I was thinking of Smallville! -MMoM
|
Kelso Commodore
|
posted December 11, 2001 00:56
quote: Originally posted by SchwEnt: 2151 First contact with Klingon Empire
Now that is funny. ------------------ "Ya know, when we finally get through this, I'd like to locate and raid a kitchen somewhere." -- James T. Kirk (Dagger of the Mind)
| |
Contact Us | http://www.treknation.com/
Copyright 2000 © The Trek Nation. All rights reserved.
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47e
|
|
|