Registered: Jan 2004
Location:
Posts: 66

And I can't believe there are a few Pats fans who say Manning is better. Manning is a choker and while he does rack up yards with the unbelievable amount of offensive talent, he always crumbles on pressure situations. Put Damon Huard in there and I bet u he puts up the numbers Manning puts up. Manning is so overrated...

Jets 41- Colts 0 (2 ints, maybe more i forgot)
Pats 24 - Colts 14 (4 ints, and couldnt take his team to the endzone on a 2 minute drive)

Report this post to an administrator IP: Logged

Registered: Oct 2003
Location:
Posts: 96

quote:

---

Originally posted by ajetsfan
And I can't believe there are a few Pats fans who say Manning is better. Manning is a choker and while he does rack up yards with the unbelievable amount of offensive talent, he always crumbles on pressure situations. Put Damon Huard in there and I bet u he puts up the numbers Manning puts up. Manning is so overrated...

Jets 41- Colts 0 (2 ints, maybe more i forgot)
Pats 24 - Colts 14 (4 ints, and couldnt take his team to the endzone on a 2 minute drive)

---

Report this post to an administrator IP: Logged

Registered: Oct 2002
Location:
Posts: 1207

quote:

---

Originally posted by ajetsfan
And I can't believe there are a few Pats fans who say Manning is better. Manning is a choker and while he does rack up yards with the unbelievable amount of offensive talent, he always crumbles on pressure situations. Put Damon Huard in there and I bet u he puts up the numbers Manning puts up. Manning is so overrated...

Jets 41- Colts 0 (2 ints, maybe more i forgot)
Pats 24 - Colts 14 (4 ints, and couldnt take his team to the endzone on a 2 minute drive)

---

Report this post to an administrator IP: Logged

Registered: Sep 2003
Location: Indianapolis
Posts: 195

quote:

---

Originally posted by ajetsfan
And I can't believe there are a few Pats fans who say Manning is better.

---

Report this post to an administrator IP: Logged

Registered: Sep 2003
Location:
Posts: 23

Manning is the best quarterback the nfl has seen in twenty years. I feel very confident stating that point.

Manning can't play D. Manning can't play special teams. Sure, he's had his bad games, but this year was nothing short of stellar.

Manning has created stars for this Indy offence. Put any decent NFL calibur reciever on manning side, they would be dangerous.

Enough with the manning bashing. It's getting rediculous. The guy is an offensive play making machine. just not today.

We hate the Jets in Indy. Your team is on the way to being the next bungles.

Report this post to an administrator IP: Logged

Registered: Apr 2001
Location: Southern Indiana, formerly of Indy
Posts: 560

This guy is a Patriots fan disguised as a Jets fan to make it look like he doesn't have some bias. You veil is thin.

I'd hate to see what Manning would do against the Colts defense. It would be ugly.

The two can't be compared, and anyone who does think Brady is better doesn't have an objective bone in his body or doesn't know anything about football.

__________________
"In my humble opinion, which - of course - is right."

"Ending a sentence with a preposition is something up with which I will not put."

"Stamp out and eradicate superfulous redundancy."

Report this post to an administrator IP: Logged

Registered: Jan 2004
Location:
Posts: 64

It's Bill Russell vs Wilt Chamberlain....

Wilt fans will point out that Wilt has much better stats and Russell has the better team, Russell fans will point out the rings, and the fact that Wilts team is hardly shabby.


I love the "Peyton makes stars" argument.... Pollard is a near pro-bowl TE, Dallas Clark is a stud, Waynes a #1, Harrison is in his own right one of the best recievers of the past 20 years, Edge is in his own right a stud RB, the OL isn't dogmeat..... Brady has lower offensive wattage albeit a much better defense.

I'm going to take Brady over Manning for the same reason I'd take Montana over Marino. You could argue it I guess.

Report this post to an administrator IP: Logged

Registered: May 2003
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 85

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/fo...jets/index.html

unlike the jets, we will be back.

and, i'd take montana over marino anyday. marino always seemed like a sore sport. at this point, i'd say montana is the best qb to ever play the game.

tom brady is no joe montana. we can argue this back and forth but the truth will be revealed over time.

Report this post to an administrator IP: Logged