Lindsey drove Beth and me back to my house. Beth and I were in the back just holding each other. That's all we needed right now, just to hold each other. It felt wonderful to see the sparkle in her multicolored eyes. It felt so wonderful to hear her angelic voice again. My life wasn't complete without her. Eventually, we got to the house. Time seemed to fly when I was with this woman. I walked in my house to see Amy lying on my couch with her feet on my coffee table. Liger ran over to me and barked his ass off as usual when I came home. I told him to hush. I couldn't believe the audacity of this bitch. I told her to never put her feet on my furniture. Matt must have been here too. She smiled at me. I looked her like I was The Rock and she was Kurt Angle.

"What are you doing?" I asked.

"Watching television." Amy said. She waved to Beth and Lindsey.

"WHAT are you doin'?" I yelled.

"Who you yellin' at?" She replied.

"You, bitch!"

Amy got up off the couch and got in my face. We looked at each other dead in the eyes.

"What did you call me?" She asked seriously.

I was about to say it but Lindsey pulled Amy back. We were about to fight again.

"Jeff, I'm so happy to see y'all fight again but don't you ever call a woman that. You understand?" Beth said.

I sighed and nodded. Then, I turned away. I could hear Amy mutter something about me under her breath. I ran over to her and slapped her. Out of nowhere, Matt shoved me away from punching Amy again. Liger ran over to Matt and barked at him. Matt looked at Amy's face with concern in his eyes. Beth grabbed my shirt and dragged me to my bedroom. She slammed the door behind me.

"What's up with you? Don't you dare hit a girl like that again! I don't care if you don't like Amy but you don't have any right to hurt her! Do you understand?"

"Yeah." I shrugged.

The phone rang.

"I'LL GET IT, MOTHERFUCKER!" Amy screamed.

I tried to get up but Beth gave me a look and I sat down. The next thing I knew, the door swung open. Amy was standing in the doorway with a huge smile on her face.

"Telephone." She said calmly.

Something wasn't right. I looked at Beth. I slowly reached for the phone. Amy walked over to it and handed it to me.

"Here you go. Enjoy your conversation." She said with that calm tone.

"There's gonna be some drama in this house tonight." Amy mumbled to herself.

"Hello?" I spoke into the phone.

"Hi, Jeff. It's Stephanie."

My mind went blank. I was on my way home to end my relationship with Stephanie but I never got the chance since Beth and Lindsey were headed where I was headed too. Damn, I was in trouble.

"Hey, Steph. How are you?"

"Fine. You said we needed to talk about something."

"We do but not right now."

I saw Beth walk over to the caller ID. I cursed under my breath. She looked at the damn thing and looked at me.

"Who is that, Jeff?" Beth asked.

"No one."

She gave me a weird look.

"You've never lied to me before. Don't start now."

"It's no one important."

Beth rolled her eyes and opened the door where Amy was standing with a phone in her hand. She smiled evilly at me and gave it to her.

"Who is this?" Beth spoke into the phone.

"Stephanie."

"Why are you calling this house?" Beth put her hands on her waist.

"This is my boyfriend's house. Who is this?"

Beth looked at me. A tear fell from her eye. She quickly wiped it away.

"His ex-girlfriend."

She threw the phone at me. I ducked out of the way. Beth started crying again and walked over to the drawer where most of her clothes were. She took all of them out, walked in my closet and got a suitcase out. She dropped all of them in there.

"Steph, I'll call you back."

"No, you won't. Who is that?"

"That's what we need to talk about. I think we need to..."

"I wasted too much of my time with you. You're nothing but a cheat, liar and a heartbreaker. I hate you! I hope you die!" Beth screamed.

Tears filled in my eyes. Beth sobbed and stumbled into the bathroom.

"...Jeff, were you gonna dump me just then?" Stephanie asked.

It was then, I realized that I had to make a choice. It was either gonna be Stephanie or Beth.

Next Part