| Contestant | Song |
Randy | Paula |
Simon |
Elisabeth LeTendre
 |
I Want To Dance With Somebody |
Yo, yo, yo man, that was hot | I second that, your vocals were spot on tonight, great job | Good singer, cheap performance |
Jon-Peter Lewis
 |
Tiny Dancer |
Dude, your voice sounds cartoonish sometimes | You've got a lot of passion, I think you did a nice job | I can't look at you and say you are an American Idol |
Amy Adams
 |
Power Of Love |
You've got the personality, you can sing. Very, very good | You're phenomenal | I look at you and think "Cabaret Idol" rather than "American Idol" |
Eric Yoder
 |
In The Still Of The Night |
It was all right, but not really exciting | There's no question you have a very nice voice | You're like Clay Aiken, without the personality |
Jonah Moananu
 |
I Wish |
You didn't show the vocal skills, man | I still think your voice sounded good | I just don't think you're very good |
Charly Lowry
 |
Chain Of Fools |
Pitch-wise, you were all over the place | I'm looking for more of a tighter performance | I don't think it was a great performance, but you have a very, very good voice potential |
Leah LaBelle
 |
I Have Nothing |
I love the tone and sound of your voice | You've got star quality and it really shows | You have alomst everything right, but you're not quite ready yet |
Latoya London
 |
All By Myself |
The best I've heard since we started this thing | Unbelievable | It was a suberb, outstanding performance |
