| North and South | Grainger Rangers | The Slumlords |
| McCarthy-isms | Eastside Ringers | Hunky Town Tigers |
| Lake Erie Longshots | Toledo Testers | Sylvania Possums |
| Glass City Thunder | Eastside Story | Seagate Swindlers |
| Category | Holder | Year |
| Batting Average | Eastside Ringers (.3034) | 2007 |
| Homeruns | Hunky Town Tigers (292) | 1987 |
| Runs Batted In | Hunky Town Tigers (1067) | 1999 |
| Stolen Bases | Lake Erie Longshots (194) | 1987 |
| ERA | Eastside Ringers (3.00) | 2008 |
| Wins | Eastside Story (109) | 2000 |
| Saves | North and South (108) | 2005 |
| Hit/Walk Ratio | Seagate Swindlers (1.184) | 2005 |
| Total Points (11 team league) | Lake Erie Longshots (78.0) | 1993 |
| Total Points (12 team league) | Seagate Swindlers (90.5) | 1994 |
| Category | Holder | Year |
| Batting Average | Northwood Tschoncks (.248) | 1989 |
| Homeruns | Seagate Swindlers (90) | 2005 |
| Runs Batted In | Seagate Swindlers (441) | 2005 |
| Stolen Bases | Seagate Swindlers (33) | 2005 |
| ERA | McCarthy-isms (5.91) | 1996 |
| Wins | Eastside Ringers (24) | 2007 |
| Saves | Lake Erie Longshots (0) | 2001 |
| Hit/Walk Ratio | McCarthy-isms (1.6304) | 1996 |
| Total Points | Manila Folders (17.5) | 1987 |
